Friday, September 19, 2014

Book to Movie: This Is Where I Leave You

The movie This Is Where I Leave You opens today in theaters nationwide with a powerhouse cast that includes Tina Fey, Jane Fonda, Jason Bateman and Adam Driver. I had the opportunity to see a screening earlier this week and thoroughly enjoyed the movie. In fact, I was surprised by how much I enjoyed the movie because I have been evangelizing this book since I read it a number of years ago (I have recommended it to so many since then) and I was a little hesitant about the movie since they often disappoint as compared to the book. I knew, however, that the author, Jonathan Tropper, has been very involved in the movie and had even written the screenplay - that, coupled with the cast, convinced me to give it a try. And I was not disappointed in the least.

 This Is Where I Leave You tells the story of the Altman family and the movie opens with the death of the patriarch, Mort Altman. Recently widowed and mother to the clan, Hilary Altman, played by Jane Fonda, informs the family that their father's dying wish was to have the entire family sit shiva for him. This places the adult Altman children in their childhood home receiving family and friends offering their condolences for seven days. It is clear there is a lot of love in the family but there is also tension which is exacerbated by their grief and being forced into close proximity day after day. As the week progresses, each sibling has personal revelations and secrets are exposed.

 I had the chance, with some other bloggers, to speak with Jonathan Tropper about the movie and the book to move transformation. I was especially interested in his thoughts as the author and screenwriter on the differences between the two media and the impact on his story.

  What do you think TV and movies can do better than books in telling a story? What can books do better than something on screen?

A movie has the benefit of being able to transport for an hour and a half, two hours with no interruptions and give you the whole story and take you on the entire journey in a kind of encapsulated way.  And you just sit back and watch it all unfold...the book kind of lingers.  But you have to kind of refocus.  So, that's also the plus of the book is that you can live with the characters in the book over a period of weeks, whereas you know a movie you're done in two hours . . .I think you know the rest is kind of obvious.  The movies can give you score, and the movies can give you mood, and the movies can give you sort of wonderfully comedic actors who can make you laugh in a way that the narrative can't.
And on the other hand, the book can take you much deeper into their minds and their emotional states and really make you understand them in a way that in a movie sometimes you really have to do that math yourself.
One thing I definitely noticed in the movie is the score/soundtrack - it enhanced my enjoyment of the story and the nostalgic selection of 80's and 90's tunes was perfect for a group of siblings returning to their childhood home. It certainly added to the ability of the movie to transport.

I noticed while watching the movie that I felt more empathetic to Judd (played by Jason Bateman) than I did while reading the book. I was interested to hear Jonathan Tropper's thoughts on my different reactions to the character in the movie versus the book:
There's two things there that you're reacting to.  The first is I think just that you know Jason Bateman happens to be a very charming guy.  He’s extremely likable.  And he brings that into whatever he does.
But beyond that, in the book I could allow the character to be slightly more reprehensible and slightly less sympathetic because you can kind of do that in literature and still redeem the character because I'm giving you the inner workings of his mind.
So, I'm sort of bringing you to a place where you understand.  And even if you find some of his behavior a little outrageous, in the movie because I can't make you privy to the inner workings of his mind and his thought process, I have to work with him a little harder to make sure I'm not making him you know too much of an asshole.
And so, there is some balance in that, where there are certain things he did in the book that I wouldn't have him do in the movie because I wouldn't be able to explain to you why he's doing it.
Screenplay writer and author, Jonathan Tropper (on set with book in hand)

Finally, I observed that the movie is so close to the book - which as a lover of the book, I appreciated. Tropper, as the screenwriter, was able to ensure the story stayed close to the one he wrote in the book but he also gave credit to the director (Shawn Levy) saying "he [Shawn Levy] was just such a fan of the book that we were actually in this strangely reverse position where the director was actually pushing me to be truer to my own source material than I was being".

This book is a wonderful book to movie transformation and I enjoyed hearing Tropper's thoughts on the differences between the media and how he brought the characters to life in the movie versus in the book.

If you are looking for a comedy, with just the right touch of sentimentality (I cried twice during the movie), see This Is Where I Leave You - - it opens today (Sep 19th) at theaters nationwide.  


  1. I'm so glad to see the movie does the book justice. I can't wait to see it!

  2. We've been thinking this looked like a good one and I haven't even read the book yet. Maybe this is a case where I'll see the movie first for a change.

  3. I cried more than twice; really enjoyed it and, like you, was a huge fan of the book. Great post!

  4. Oh I'm glad to hear this stayed true to the book and is good! I was feeling sort of hesitant about watching it because I figureded my expectations were probably too high. I like Jason Bateman and Tina Fey so am looking forward to them!

  5. I loved this book, too, and am thrilled to hear that the movie is well done. What an amazing opportunity to talk with Tropper after viewing the film!

  6. Thanks for posting the interview - what fun! I can't wait to see the movie!

  7. I loved both the book and the movie, and was not disappointed in the least by the film, as I knew I would not be. The cast alone made me know I would love it. Thanks for sharing your thoughts and the interview with the author.

  8. I didn't realize this was made from a book. I haven't see or read it, but it looks terrific.

  9. I liked the book well enough, but the movie will probably wait until I can get it on television or dvd. great cast though

  10. Hi. It appears you are using your blog. But I never found a review page for the Ireland reading challenge and am perplexed that questions on the sign-up page didn't appear to get answered. If you don't imagine you or Carrie will have time for an interactive challenge next year, let me know (at my blog please). I'd be glad to host.

  11. Great post!! I nominated you for the Liebster Award!

  12. I'm glad to know the movie is good. I just finished the book and liked it a lot. He's a great writer. Cheers.

  13. I really enjoyed the movie, and didn't realize it was a book until I Googled it trying to figure out why the actress who played Judd's wife looked so familiar, and stumbled across a reference to the book.

    I think the comment about how Judd is less of a nice guy in the book is interesting, because he is definitely the hero of the movie.

    It reminded me a bit of August Osage County--same premise--but This Is Where I Leave You was infinitely more enjoyable.

    I've been thinking about getting a copy of the book. Seems like a good airplane book to me.

  14. Excellent review. Thanks for this kind of article.
    Download Latest Movie