Friday, May 18, 2012

Review: Lucky Child by Loung Ung

Loung Ung lived in Cambodia with her family. When the Khmer Rouge assumed control of the country in the seventies, much of her family were brutally murdered. Ung recounts that period of her life in First They Killed My Father; Lucky Child continues with the story of her immigration to the United States at the age of ten and her journey back to Cambodia for the sister she left behind. This memoir poignantly captures the immigrant experience of Luong but it also speaks to the power of a sibling connection and how it drives Luong back to a place where she had suffered so much.

The memoir opens with Loung’s arrival in Vermont from Cambodia with her brother and sister in law. We learn that they have left behind family members including their sister Chou because there wasn’t enough money to take everyone - as the youngest, Loung is selected as the “lucky child”. There is a heart wrenching parting scene as Loung leaves her village to travel to the US and is literally pulled away from her last surviving sister and clings on to her until their hands no longer touch. The absence of the touch of her sister’s hand and the guilt over being the chosen one will haunt Loung as she settles into her life in Vermont.

The Ungs face typical immigrant challenges as they settle into their new lives. Even as their plane from Cambodia descends to the airport, Loung’s sister in law insists she put on a clean new shirt so she doesn’t look “off the boat”. Before even setting foot on foreign soil, the Ung’s are aware of their otherness and strive to minimize and conceal it. Of course, their immigrant story is heightened by all they have left behind and the memories that haunt them- I can’t imagine bearing the insults which are often part of assimilation while also mourning the loss of so many family members. Loung and her brother Meng are not only alone in the United States but truly alone in the world after the deaths of  their siblings and parents.

In many ways, their sister Chou is equally alone in Cambodia. As the chapters alternate between Luong’s new life in the United States with Chou’s in Cambodia, a contrast is drawn between their lives but there is also an interesting parallel.  This juxtaposition serves as a reminder of no matter the struggles faced by immigrants, often the life they have left behind is even more difficult. As Loung faces the sting of shame when she uses food stamps, Chou struggles to have enough rice for each meal. Chou is surrounded by the aftermath of the Khmer Rouge regime including all the suffering of a people in a land that has been systematically decimated. Luong is constantly haunted by the memories of what she witnessed while in Cambodia and the loss of those closest to her.

Lucky Child is very readable, despite the sometimes difficult subject matter, and I had to remind myself several times that this was a memoir and not a work of fiction. Luong tells her story with such honesty but also without sentimentality. She frankly recounts her experiences without a trace of self-pity. This very straightforward style adds to the power of the book. In Lucky Child, Loung bears witness to the aftermath of the horror of the genocide in Cambodia and in doing so ensures the atrocities are not forgotten.

Lucky Child is the second book by Loung Ung - her third book, Lulu in the Sky picks up where Lucky Child leaves off and recounts her move into adulthood. You can see reviews of all of Ung's books by checking out the other stops on the TLC Book Tour. 

14 comments:

  1. I never tire of immigrant stories. Can you imagine having to decide who would get to go and who would be left behind? This book sounds amazing!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I know - it is hard to imagine how much this family had to face at a such a young age. It really is a great story of survival!

      Delete
  2. I love it when a memoir pulls me in just like a novel, though it it sometimes jarring to realize that I'm reading facts not fiction.

    Thanks for being a part of the tour!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I can't even imagine the guilt Loung had to deal with after leaving behind members of her family. Maybe akin to survivor's guilt? However it felt, her story sounds so inspiring!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. yes - I think she felt so much guilt for being the chosen child. Apparently some of the effects of that can be seen in her third memoir "Lulu in the Sky"

      Delete
  4. I don't read much nonfiction, but this one really intrigues me. I'll have to track down her first book too.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Wow this sounds like an incredibly difficult book to read but so good!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi there,

    Hmmm interesting stuff

    Thanks
    harry

    ReplyDelete
  7. How interesting to have an immigrant memoir told in 2 voices, 1 abroad and 1 left behind. I've seen that device in fiction but not in nonfiction. I'm also trying to get my head around a Cambodian in Vermont - so much adjustment to climate as well as culture. In Maine we have a sizable Somalian immigrant community. The kids at my kids' school have integrated well but there are issues like girls not being able to wear shorts for sports. Their urban school has done well at accommodating them but I can imagine that a rural community might not have had as much experience.

    ReplyDelete
  8. This sounds great. I am always fascinated how immigrants from different countries approach entry into the U.S. and their different mindsets.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I can only imagine what you read about if you had to remind yourself that this wasn't fiction. I'm glad you liked it! Thanks for participating in the tour.

    ReplyDelete
  10. This sounds so harrowing! I can't what it would be like to be "chosen" to survive and "chosen" to face possible death. Sounds powerful - I will have to check out her previous book.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I had not heard of these books, what a moving story she tells. Have you read Lisa See's fiction, Shanghai Girls and Dreams of Joy?

    ReplyDelete